KEVIN DORST
  • Bio
  • Research
  • Teaching
  • General Audience
  • Substack

Stranger Apologies

Pandemic Polarization is Reasonable

3/21/2020

7 Comments

 
(2500 words; 11 minute read.)

Last week I had back-to-back phone calls with two friends in the US. The first told me he wasn’t too worried about Covid-19 because the flu already is a pandemic, and although this is worse, it’s not that much worse. The second was—as he put it—at “DEFCON 1”: preparing for the possibility of a societal breakdown, and wondering whether he should buy a gun.

I bet this sort of thing sounds familiar. People have had very different reactions to the pandemic. Why? And equally importantly: what are we to make of such differences?

The question is political. Though things are changing fast, there remains a substantial partisan divide in people’s reactions: for example, one poll from early this week found that 76% of Democrats saw Covid as a “real threat”, compared to only 40% of Republicans (continuing the previous week’s trend).

What are we to make of this “pandemic polarization”? Must Democrats attribute partisan-motivated complacency to Republicans, or Republicans attribute partisan-motivated panic to Democrats? 

I’m going to make the case that the answer is no: there is a simple, rational process that can drive these effects. Therefore we needn’t—I’d say shouldn’t—take the differing reaction of the “other side” as yet another reason to demonize them.  

Read More
7 Comments

The Rational Question

3/14/2020

2 Comments

 
I just published a new piece in the Oxonian Review. It argues that a general problem with claimed demonstrations of irrationality is their reliance on standard economic models of rational belief and action, and illustrates the point by explaining some great work by Tom Kelly on the sunk cost fallacy and by Brian Hedden on hindsight bias.

Check out the full article here.
2 Comments

    Kevin Dorst

    Philosopher at MIT, trying to convince people that their opponents are more reasonable than they think

    Quick links:
    - What this blog is about
    - ​Reasonably Polarized series
    - RP Technical Appendix

    Follow me on Twitter​ or join the newsletter for updates.

    RSS Feed

    Archives

    June 2023
    April 2021
    March 2021
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020

    Categories

    All
    All Most Read
    Conjunction Fallacy
    Framing Effects
    Gambler's Fallacy
    Overconfidence
    Polarization
    Rationalization
    Reasonably Polarized Series

  • Bio
  • Research
  • Teaching
  • General Audience
  • Substack